Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred
16758
post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-16758,single-format-standard,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,side_area_uncovered_from_content,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-17.2,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-5.6,vc_responsive

We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

When we talk, we follow certain ground rules, which are set out in what philosophers call “language games”. Each game has its own set of rules – but problems arise when not everyone is clear which game is being played.

Perhaps most important is the informing game, in which we use words to give people useful information about the world: “It’s raining outside”, “The meeting is in Room 12”, “That’s vodka, not water”.

Illustration: Simon Letch
Illustration: Simon Letch

In this game, the No. 1 rule is to tell the truth. If we break it, we can rightly be held to account for lying, or at least misleading. Without this truth-telling rule, our interactions in many walks of life would break down, from the science lab to the schoolroom to the courthouse, and anywhere else that evidence, facts and a shared understanding of reality matter.

But there are also language games in which the truth-telling rule does not apply. If I say that a horse walked into a bar, you should know I am not playing the informing game. To complain that I am lying, or to demand evidence— which horse? which bar? — would be like a soccer player on the rugby field asking why other players are handling the ball.

Mixing the rules of our language games is a major factor in the deepening crisis of “post truth” public discourse. Consider Donald Trump, who has made more than 2000 false statements in public since his inauguration as US President, and countless more before that.

To cite just one example, in a 2016 campaign speech Trump stated that US black youth unemployment was at 58 per cent, when in fact the US Bureau of Labor Statistics put the figure at 21 per cent. Fact-checkers wanted to hold Trump accountable for having broken the truth-telling rule. But as author Salena Zito explained, his supporters couldn’t have cared less about the facts: “When Trump makes claims like this, the press takes him literally, but not seriously; his supporters take him seriously, but not literally.”

For supporters, Trump was not playing the informing game, he was playing the signalling game. It’s like joking, but without the laughs. In the signalling game, language is for aligning with people, affiliating with them, tapping into their views and feelings. Not for conveying the facts.

Fraser Anning in the Senate on Wednesday.
Fraser Anning in the Senate on Wednesday.Photo: AAP

Or consider Senator Fraser Anning’s maiden speech to Parliament this week. In a formal, high-stakes, on-record speech, one might think that firm evidence would be indispensable to a solid argument, yet fact-checkers found numerous inaccuracies. Then again, as a statement intended to set the tone of Anning’s tenure and to grab hold of a news cycle, perhaps facts were less important for Anning than signalling the intended sentiment.

With “dogwhistle” expressions, a speaker can signal certain ideas without being accountable for having expressed them. We might ask whether Anning’s reference to the “final solution” was a botched attempt at dogwhistling, or whether it was meant to be the foghorn that it was.

The problem is not confined to the political right. Take the recent controversy over The New York Times hiring author Sarah Jeong. She has come under fire for the content of her Twitter feed over recent years, including quips like “f— white women lol” and “#cancelwhitepeople”.

As author Iona Italia put it, Jeong’s supporters argue that “this kind of speech cannot be considered racism, because its intent is simply to signal allegiance to the cause of social justice”. Jeong herself said that the tweets were “intended as satire”. Either way, when being taken at their word, this speaker’s response is not to defend the words, but to say that they were part of a language game in which the truth-telling rule did not apply.

Donald Trump has made more than 2000 false statements in public since his inauguration.
Donald Trump has made more than 2000 false statements in public since his inauguration.Photo: AP

The problem is that the “don’t take me literally” defence can always be made after the fact, when the content of what one said has turned out to be problematic. How do we know what games people really were playing and when the signalling defence is an attempt to escape accountability?

Edgy humour has always exploited this ambiguity: maybe I mean this, maybe I don’t. Is the onus on us as listeners and readers to determine which language game a speaker was playing before we call them out for breaking the rules?  In private life, perhaps, but in public discourse, we are not, and should not, be free to just play any old game with language. Why not? Because truth matters. If I take a falsehood literally, I am now ill-informed and in the real world this means I may then make poor decisions with real consequences.

Consider the reckless statements about smoking that British politician Nigel Farage has made in public: that people should ignore the World Health Organisation’s recommendations, because the organisation is “just another club of ‘clever people’ who want to bully us and tell us what to do”; that “the doctors have got it wrong on smoking”. These statements may have been good plays in the signalling game, but public statements will always circulate beyond their original context and so the collateral effects of such signalling are plain dangerous.

The philosopher Harry Frankfurt uses the technical term “bullshit” for the language game in which truth does not enter into the rules. It is the most dangerous game in public discourse because it threatens to normalise the idea that people are not accountable for saying things that are false. Of course, the “don’t take me literally” game has its place, but in public discourse it introduces ambiguities and escape hatches that play on the wider audience’s lack of common ground: if only you were part of the in-crowd, you’d have known not to take me literally.

If we continue to allow signalling and other forms of “bullshit” to corrode the link between language and truth, we stand to lose the most precious thing that language gives us: the capacity to anchor social life in a common frame of knowledge and understanding of reality.

Reality does not care about our social signals. Being sceptical of “clever people” won’t stop smoking from damaging your health. Only by privileging the game of evidence-based reasoning can we find paths that distinguish the true from the false, the safe from the dangerous, the sensible from the stupid, and even the good from the bad.

Nick Enfield is a professor of linguistics at the University of Sydney and head of the Post Truth Initiative. He is a panellist in a discussion on truth decay at the University of Sydney’s US Studies Centre on August 22.

Originally published on The Sydney Morning Herald

70 Comments
  • generic cialis without doctor's prescription
    Posted at 03:42h, 20 April

    generic cialis without doctor’s prescription

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics cost
    Posted at 06:03h, 20 April

    ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics cost

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • viagra for sale in canada
    Posted at 17:23h, 21 April

    viagra for sale in canada

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • generic ventolin
    Posted at 15:39h, 23 April

    generic ventolin

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • naltrexone brand name
    Posted at 09:10h, 30 April

    naltrexone brand name

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • viagra without doctor prescription
    Posted at 16:24h, 04 May

    viagra without doctor prescription

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • viagra how it works
    Posted at 21:11h, 08 May

    viagra how it works

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • buy tylenol
    Posted at 21:17h, 08 May

    buy tylenol

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • buy chloroquine
    Posted at 16:54h, 09 May

    buy chloroquine

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • hydroxychloroquine over the counter uk
    Posted at 07:12h, 03 June

    hydroxychloroquine over the counter uk

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • viagra without prescriptions in usa
    Posted at 20:01h, 29 June

    viagra without prescriptions in usa

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • cialis ed
    Posted at 17:27h, 01 July

    cialis ed

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • generic viagra 100mg pills erections
    Posted at 15:13h, 11 July

    generic viagra 100mg pills erections

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • generic for latisse eyelash growth
    Posted at 06:33h, 14 July

    generic for latisse eyelash growth

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • tadalafil without a doctor's prescription
    Posted at 20:29h, 14 July

    tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • croatia viagra 100mg
    Posted at 06:43h, 23 July

    croatia viagra 100mg

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • efcaxdszdfszgd
    Posted at 17:35h, 29 July

    Title

    […]check below, are some absolutely unrelated internet sites to ours, even so, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  • canadian generic viagra online
    Posted at 18:09h, 29 July

    canadian generic viagra online

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • m980u9oy9y98o8y9pm
    Posted at 20:20h, 30 July

    Title

    […]just beneath, are numerous totally not associated websites to ours, nonetheless, they’re certainly really worth going over[…]

  • m90uojmuy7hjhhhh
    Posted at 18:07h, 31 July

    Title

    […]below you will find the link to some sites that we feel it is best to visit[…]

  • rxc43rw435tr53t453t
    Posted at 07:27h, 02 August

    Title

    […]Here are some of the web sites we suggest for our visitors[…]

  • buy hydroxychloroquine online
    Posted at 18:08h, 07 August

    buy hydroxychloroquine online

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • Airport Eagles customer login
    Posted at 17:06h, 11 August

    Title

    […]one of our guests recently suggested the following website[…]

  • Wall Tapestry Dorm
    Posted at 20:52h, 30 August

    Title

    […]Every the moment in a when we opt for blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the latest sites that we choose […]

  • cxqw234xracrwcr4
    Posted at 21:49h, 31 August

    Title

    […]please take a look at the web-sites we comply with, including this a single, as it represents our picks from the web[…]

  • xdsffx4crta4rtxa34w
    Posted at 18:49h, 01 September

    Title

    […]the time to study or visit the material or web sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  • buy cialis
    Posted at 12:04h, 22 September

    buy cialis

    Nick Enfield | We all play language games – but the boundaries are getting dangerously blurred

  • tadalafil generic pills
    Posted at 11:16h, 30 September

    cheapest generic cialis

    cialis pricing

  • cialis online pharmacy
    Posted at 18:36h, 04 October

    cialis otc

    cialis tadalafil

  • viagra online
    Posted at 22:25h, 07 October

    viagra prescription

    viagra cost

  • viagra cost
    Posted at 22:56h, 08 October

    buy generic viagra online

    order viagra

  • otc viagra
    Posted at 01:49h, 14 October

    buy generic viagra online

    where to buy viagra

  • online viagra
    Posted at 18:59h, 14 October

    otc viagra

    online viagra

  • viagra alternatives for sale
    Posted at 03:06h, 20 October

    viagra online nz

    can i buy viagra in a chemist

  • buy cialis in india
    Posted at 23:53h, 22 October

    cialis jakarta

    buy cialis online in usa

  • price of viagra tablets in india
    Posted at 00:49h, 25 October

    best place to buy generic viagra

    generic viagra 100mg tablets

  • 36 hour cialis
    Posted at 20:26h, 26 October

    cialis info

    cialis soft tabs online

  • buy cialis mexico
    Posted at 00:21h, 29 October

    cialis tolerance

    pink cialis

  • to buy viagra in hyderabad
    Posted at 23:36h, 30 October

    viagra vietnam

    generic viagra professional 100mg

  • uscojufm9r4tue4urtse4
    Posted at 20:06h, 04 November

    Title

    […]please check out the web pages we comply with, including this 1, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  • germany
    Posted at 23:29h, 06 November

    Title

    […]below you will find the link to some web sites that we believe you must visit[…]

  • mua hạt macca ở đâu uy tín
    Posted at 08:16h, 07 November

    Title

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated information, nonetheless truly worth taking a search, whoa did one find out about Mid East has got far more problerms too […]

  • https://www.manytube.net/
    Posted at 13:46h, 09 November

    Title

    […]although web sites we backlink to below are considerably not associated to ours, we feel they’re really really worth a go as a result of, so possess a look[…]

  • https://royalcbd.com/product/cbd-oil-2500mg/
    Posted at 14:29h, 09 November

    Title

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a handful of unrelated information, nevertheless definitely worth taking a search, whoa did one particular master about Mid East has got far more problerms also […]

  • https://royalcbd.com/product/cbd-roll-on-gel/
    Posted at 22:44h, 09 November

    Title

    […]Every when in a whilst we opt for blogs that we read. Listed below would be the newest internet sites that we decide on […]

  • cbd gummies
    Posted at 02:10h, 10 November

    Title

    […]The data mentioned within the post are a few of the most effective readily available […]

  • https://royalcbd.com/product/cbd-gummies-10mg/
    Posted at 06:20h, 10 November

    Title

    […]one of our visitors lately recommended the following website[…]

  • https://royalcbd.com/product/cbd-oil-1000mg/
    Posted at 07:28h, 10 November

    Title

    […]the time to read or visit the subject material or web-sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  • viagra samples from doctor
    Posted at 07:54h, 10 November

    generic viagra australia

    viagra medicare

  • https://royalcbd.com/product/cbd-cream/
    Posted at 08:15h, 10 November

    Title

    […]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[…]