Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well
16686
post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-16686,single-format-standard,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,side_area_uncovered_from_content,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-17.2,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-5.6,vc_responsive

We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

In our new normal, experts are dismissed and alternative facts flagrantly offered. This suspicion of specialists is part of a bigger problem

Image: March For Science In New York City, 22 April 2017. Photograph: Erik McGregor/Pacific/Barcroft

We often defer to others’ expertise, and for good reason. The entire edifice of modern society only exists thanks to the division of labour, from construction to machine operation to medical treatment. The system works as long as we have trustin others’ knowledge, skills and intentions.

This trust is often tested, most notably of late in relation to those who specialise in politics. People-powered movements from anarchism to populism want to see equality of participation in political decision-making. Indeed, this is at the heart of all versions of democracy. It raises the question of whether we should trust political insiders.

Populism has done well by questioning the value of career politicians and other members of the establishment, instead celebrating the possibility that positions of political power can, and should, be occupied by outsiders. Pauline Hanson surprised many by winning office in Queensland in the 1990s on a “people versus elites” campaign. Many similar examples have since gone all the way to the top. Many argued that Donald Trump was not qualified for the US presidency because he had never held public office and did not have the skills for the job. Those arguments failed to prevent him gaining office.

Those who prevailed have exploited the tension between ideals of equal access on the one hand, and deference to expertise on the other. While we might debate the wisdom of trusting political insiders, the suspicion of specialists and experts has begun to contaminate a much bigger ecology of knowledge and practice in our society.

The result is post-truth discourse. In our new normal, experts are dismissed, alternative facts are (sometimes flagrantly) offered, and public figures can offer opinions on pretty much anything. And thanks to social media, pretty much anyone can be a public figure. In much public discourse, identity outranks arguments, and we are seeing either a lack of interest in evidence, or worse, an erosion of trust in the fundamental norms around people’s accountability for the things we say.

Australia offers its share of examples. Last year, in relation to the Adani coal mine, Anthony Lynham stated that “Queensland taxpayers will not be funding any infrastructure for this project”, but Queenslanders as federal taxpayers would fund infrastructure via the proposed billion dollar loan to Adani. And when Tony Abbott opened the massive Caval Ridge mine in Central Queensland in 2014, he said “coal is good for humanity”.

The overwhelming majority of people who are professionally qualified to evaluate scientific evidence on the matter know otherwise .

This cannot end well. We can’t afford to dismiss the testimony of those with scientific and technical expertise. Like the airline pilots who we rightly trust to fly our planes, scientists have knowledge and skills that many of us both lack and need.

The scientific community is responding with a growing counter-movement. A global March for Science on Earth Day in April 2017 saw more than 600 cities participate. Thousands have signed a pro-truth pledge , with commitments including “fact-check information to confirm it is true before accepting and sharing it’, “reevaluate if my information is challenged, retract it if I cannot verify it”, and “distinguish between my opinion and the facts”.

Sticking to commitments like these is hard work and does not necessarily come naturally. The struggle to do so encapsulates two fundamental things about what it means to think and talk like a human.

The first is that while human higher reasoning is a celebrated capacity of our species, we are in fact notoriously poor reasoners. Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman, among many others, has shown that our reasoning is riddled with cognitive bugs and biases. The confirmation bias is one of the most insidious. We are highly likely to believe or at least accept and repeat statements that support our established views, even when little or no evidence is given to support those statements. Yet we are unlikely to accept or repeat statements that go counter to our established views, even when they are well-supported by evidence. This bias is the engine that drives the click-by-click spread of fake news and other dangerous nonsense.

The second thing is that humans are psychologically capable of the remarkable feat of focusing our attention on our own thought processes and deliberately overriding them. We can identify our own flawed habits of thinking and then use more deliberate cognition to outsmart these habits and avoid the pitfalls. Much of higher learning involves the cultivation of just this capacity.

Because the deliberate attention to our own faults of reasoning requires vigilance, people need to be motivated to put in the hard work needed. The solution that has worked well so far is to maintain social norms by which we agree to be accountable to evidence and other elements of rational argumentation. This in turn has given us reason to rein in our more instinctive, biased patterns of reasoning.

The post-truth crisis is none other than the breakdown of these norms.

Originally published on The Guardian Opinion

79 Comments
  • naltrexone brand name
    Posted at 11:57h, 30 April

    naltrexone brand name

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • cheap viagra
    Posted at 20:10h, 04 May

    cheap viagra

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • how long does it take for a 100mg viagra to kick in?
    Posted at 23:49h, 08 May

    how long does it take for a 100mg viagra to kick in?

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • chloroquine generic brand
    Posted at 18:31h, 09 May

    chloroquine generic brand

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • cialis coupon
    Posted at 00:37h, 17 May

    cialis cost

    cialis reviews forum faq – cialis from canada cheap forum is locked – cialis from canada over the counter yim

  • generic tadalafil 20 mg
    Posted at 05:52h, 23 May

    tadalafil

    link sponsored delivery impotence remedies cialis increases medical products viagra – cialis 20mg tablets jump to – hazard of cialis

  • cialis dosage
    Posted at 09:27h, 25 May

    cialis dosage

    cialis or viagra which is better – ed treatments for men – cialis from canada daily privacy policy

  • hydroxychloroquine price uk
    Posted at 07:52h, 03 June

    hydroxychloroquine price uk

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • generic tadalafil
    Posted at 14:21h, 05 June

    tadalafil generic best prices

    cialis harder – cialis no prescription – cialis pills wiki skin by

  • real viagra for sale
    Posted at 03:24h, 21 June

    generic viagra for sale

    viagra gtgt the best known men39s pill ltlt buy now from $1 53 per – viagra and alcohol side effects memberlist – genuine viagra viagra is it available online

  • generic viagra pills for sale
    Posted at 20:37h, 29 June

    generic viagra pills for sale

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • buy cialis
    Posted at 18:39h, 01 July

    buy cialis

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • order viagra without prescription
    Posted at 16:06h, 11 July

    order viagra without prescription

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • careprost wholesale
    Posted at 09:08h, 14 July

    careprost wholesale

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • how long does cialis last
    Posted at 22:10h, 14 July

    how long does cialis last

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • cheapest 100 viagra us
    Posted at 02:42h, 23 July

    cheapest 100 viagra us

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • efcaxdszdfszgd
    Posted at 15:12h, 29 July

    Title

    […]below you will discover the link to some websites that we think you ought to visit[…]

  • generic viagra 20mg pills erections
    Posted at 21:57h, 29 July

    generic viagra 20mg pills erections

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well

  • m980u9oy9y98o8y9pm
    Posted at 18:29h, 30 July

    Title

    […]here are some links to web pages that we link to due to the fact we think they’re really worth visiting[…]

  • m90uojmuy7hjhhhh
    Posted at 14:17h, 31 July

    Title

    […]Here is a good Weblog You might Uncover Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]

  • rxc43rw435tr53t453t
    Posted at 05:19h, 02 August

    Title

    […]although internet websites we backlink to beneath are considerably not related to ours, we really feel they’re essentially really worth a go by means of, so have a look[…]

  • uk taxi terms and condtions
    Posted at 14:10h, 11 August

    Title

    […]we came across a cool web site that you simply might take pleasure in. Take a appear in case you want[…]

  • Chauffeur IN BRIGHTON
    Posted at 18:03h, 11 August

    Title

    […]here are some hyperlinks to internet sites that we link to due to the fact we feel they may be worth visiting[…]

  • cialis over counter at walmart
    Posted at 05:48h, 23 August

    generic cialis at walmart

    cialis 5mg canada it is currently – cialis and alcohol consumption administrators – buy affordable viagra,cialis online

  • walmart cialis
    Posted at 06:13h, 30 August

    cialis in walmart

    cialis eli lilly prescription – levitra cialis viagra – how much does cialis cost?

  • Face Mask Washable
    Posted at 19:32h, 30 August

    Title

    […]The info talked about in the article are a few of the best available […]

  • cxqw234xracrwcr4
    Posted at 18:18h, 31 August

    Title

    […]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we feel they’re really really worth a go as a result of, so possess a look[…]

  • xdsffx4crta4rtxa34w
    Posted at 14:53h, 01 September

    Title

    […]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not connected to ours, we really feel they may be essentially worth a go via, so possess a look[…]

  • cialis online cheap
    Posted at 09:13h, 22 September

    cialis online cheap

    Nick Enfield | We’re in a post-truth world with eroding trust and accountability. It can’t end well