Nick Enfield | Navigating the post-truth debate: some key co-ordinates
16714
post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-16714,single-format-standard,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,side_area_uncovered_from_content,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-17.2,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-5.6,vc_responsive

Navigating the post-truth debate: some key co-ordinates

Navigating the post-truth debate: some key co-ordinates

Image: Public anxiety about the post-truth era inspired a New York Times advertising campaign.
Nick Enfield, University of Sydney

This article is the first in a series from the Post-Truth Initiative, a Strategic Research Excellence Initiative at the University of Sydney. The series examines today’s post-truth problem in public discourse: the thriving economy of lies, bullshit and propaganda that threatens rational discourse and policy.

The project brings together scholars of media and communications, government and international relations, physics, philosophy, linguistics, and medicine, and is affiliated with the Sydney Social Sciences and Humanities Advanced Research Centre (SSSHARC), the Sydney Environment Institute and the Sydney Democracy Network.


Lies, bullshit, propaganda and conspiracy theories show no signs of going away soon, yet post-truth discourse may be one of the most pressing problems of our time. Humans have the capacity to wield unprecedented forms of power, not just over other people, as in acts of law and war, but over other forms of life, and ultimately over the environment that affords our own stability and survival.

If we want to make good decisions, those decisions had better be based on reality, and not on delusion, fantasy, or falsehood. Weakening the link between evidence and decisions not only threatens the quality of policymaking, it threatens the entire enterprise of scientific research, whose business is to find out the facts such that we may make well-informed decisions.

What exactly is post-truth discourse? How and why is it happening? And what can or should we do about it?

Beneath simple labels like post-truth, alternative facts and fake news, there is a complex set of issues. Any debate about the post-truth problem needs some common co-ordinates. Following are seven key reference points.

1. When we talk about facts, we are talking about statements

A fact is something that can be communicated in the form of a statement, where that statement happens to be true. Before you raise deep philosophical questions of what is truth, just think of everyday cases that present little challenge to our intuitions.

Suppose you reach for a bottle of water to quench your thirst, and I warn you: “That’s vodka!” It should not be hard to find out if my statement is true: just sip it and see. Many other statements are straightforward in this way: for example, My house is number 9 on my street; I have two thumbs; ice melts in the summer sun.

Not all claims to fact are easy to verify (like whether a certain foreign leader possesses weapons of mass destruction), and some are probably impossible (like whether ours is the only planet with intelligent life). And facts must be distinguished from opinions, the truth of which cannot be settled independently (like whether chocolate tastes better than vanilla).

But when we talk about facts, we are talking about the statements that describe or assert those facts, and not always the facts themselves. This means that a lot of the time, when people talk about truth, they are focusing on the statements people have made, and not on the facts those statements might describe.

2. Statements are socially constructed

Because we access facts through statements, which are acts of communication, facts are effectively always social in nature. Many scholars say facts are socially constructed. This is true in three ways.

First, facts are always presented in a particular frame. A statement of fact will always come from a person who has chosen to make just this statement and not other statements, and who has chosen to use certain words, and not others, to do it.

Intentionally or not, a person will always emphasise certain things and leave other things in the background. In addition, the language used – whether it is English, Arabic or Zulu – is itself a socially and historically constructed system, with its own in-built patterns of framing and emphasis.

Second, facts are never discovered or described in a cultural or political vacuum. Statements of fact are always a product of their context and time, and of the interests and perspectives of particular people.

Third, there is a specific class of facts that are only true because of human beliefs. An example is “That car belongs to me”. This statement of ownership is true only in terms of certain social rights and duties that are created by social institutions.

If I own the car, then, for example, I have the right to decide who can drive it and when, and the duty to pay the fine if caught by a traffic camera.

Many people agree that facts can be socially constructed in at least these ways. But it is important to note that none of these senses threaten the idea that there is a brute reality beyond our statements. No matter how I construct or frame the statement, no matter the language used, or the context of use, ice will melt in the summer sun.

3. Our beliefs are strong but unreliable

For a statement to be a fact it has to be true. Believing that it is true does not make it so. Yet we tend to show great confidence in our beliefs – both when these are based in our first-hand experience, and when these are based on what others say, as long as we trust or identify with those others. But even our most confident beliefs may not correspond with reality.

The fallibility of human memory is especially disturbing, as psychologist Elizabeth Loftus and many others have long shown.

The ways in which we talk about experiences after the fact – for example, during police interviews following a crime – can result in inaccurate or false memories. Whether by accident or intention, the mere suggestion that a particular event might have happened can result in a person firmly believing that it is true.

Another common source of false beliefs comes from our flawed human patterns of reasoning. Human cognition is not a paragon of cool reason. For example, a confirmation bias in human reasoning leads us to readily accept evidence that supports our beliefs, and yet reject or ignore equally good evidence that goes against it. Many other biases can lead us to embrace beliefs that are false, and thus in turn to make false statements.

4. Not all untruths are lies

Telling the truth is usually a simple matter. We have a belief, then we use words to convey that belief to someone else: for example, it’s vodka in the bottle, not water.

If our belief is true (it really is vodka), then our statement is true. If our belief is mistaken (it’s actually just water), then we are saying something that is false, but this is not the same as lying or bullshitting.

The liar intentionally misleads others by saying something they know is false. The bullshitter says things without knowing or caring whether they are true or false. The method of psychological bullying known as gaslighting uses lying and bullshitting to disturb others’ grip on reality.

These distinctions show people can make false statements for a range of reasons. The status of any such statement depends on the intentions of the speaker. Do they make the statement in good faith? Do they intend to deceive? Or do they simply not care?

5. Just stating a fact won’t make people believe it

Whatever your motivation, if you want people to accept a statement, then it is not enough that your statements be true. Politicians and PR merchants have long known that what we need is narrative.

The human mind is predisposed to be drawn into stories, and so a message that is clothed in a narrative arc, with a sympathetic protagonist and the tension of action, is more likely to persuade.

While scientists are trained to state the facts, many people observe with dismay the seeming hopelessness of bare statements in the face of compelling stories.

As a result, scientists are cottoning on to the fact that a statement is nothing without a story to drive it. The truth is, facts do not speak for themselves.

6. Statements are reasons

Regardless of whether the speaker is a liar or a bullshitter, a yarn-spinner or simply mistaken, a false statement is a dangerous one. This is because it can then stand as a reason for further actions and statements.

One of the main reasons we make statements at all is to motivate or justify our decisions and actions.

When I say “It’s nearly midnight”, I am not just stating a fact, I am supplying a reason for action. When I warn you “That’s vodka!”, I’m not just saying it, I’m giving you a reason not to take a big swig.

Or when the Bush administration stated in 2003 that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction, they were not just asserting a state of affairs, they were giving a reason why they should invade Iraq. It did stand as a reason, even though later the statement turned out to be false, as many people expected it would be.

By accepting or endorsing a statement, we effectively accept or endorse its consequences. So it is not surprising that the primary goal of making a statement is to get people to accept it, and not necessarily to establish that it is true.

In some settings – for example, in an idealised form of scientific discourse — the way to get people to accept a statement is precisely that: to establish that it is true. But truth is just one possible criterion for accepting statements and their consequences.

Other criteria follow people’s cognitive biases and cultural or personal preferences, play on their emotions, or appeal to their identity politics. These are some of the ways in which “alternative facts” are given currency in public discourse today.

When facts are at issue, the stakes are really about what would follow from people accepting a certain statement. This is why we have to take claims to fact seriously; not because truth should be protected in principle, but because we must live with what would follow from treating a statement as valid.

The battle over whether climate change is real is not ultimately about the truth of any given statement. It is a battle over what, if anything, is to be done.

7. Political power can always interfere

Giving reasons for action can become mere ritual if you happen to have the political power that allows you to do what you want anyway. The most extreme, brazen forms of political power do not bother with giving reasons at all.

But these extreme forms work by means of violence, and violence is based in hard facts. Bullets, shackles and prison walls do their work without any interest in your ideology or beliefs, guilt or innocence.

Political power can be used to suppress or outlaw statements of fact, to remove them from public discourse, and thus to remove their possible consequences from society. Political power can even render certain kinds of facts untrue. Social facts like ownership and membership are based in rights and duties, and can be revoked by those who control social institutions.

But there are limits to what political power can do. As much as we might wish it were possible, suppressing statements of brute fact – that ice melts in the summer sun, for instance – will never stop them from being true.

The quest for answers

The debate about rational discourse continues.

Is the problem new or old? Can we solve it, or are we doomed to grapple with falsity at every turn? Is the problem transformed by the scale of today’s communications? Is the solution a political one or a cultural one?

The ConversationThere is much to learn, and much to talk about, but meanwhile my hunch remains: facts will kill us before we kill them.

Nick Enfield, Professor and Chair of Linguistics, University of Sydney

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

623 Comments
  • how does viagra work video
    Posted at 10:48h, 04 April

    how does viagra work video

    how does viagra work video

  • couple cialis
    Posted at 12:40h, 04 April

    couple cialis

    couple cialis

  • cialis peak blood level
    Posted at 14:57h, 04 April

    cialis peak blood level

    cialis peak blood level

  • https://judahgasy592.shutterfly.com/21
    Posted at 16:38h, 04 April

    Title

    […]below you’ll find the link to some websites that we think you’ll want to visit[…]

  • how often can you take cialis
    Posted at 21:30h, 04 April

    how often can you take cialis

    how often can you take cialis

  • does express scripts cover viagra
    Posted at 00:57h, 05 April

    does express scripts cover viagra

    does express scripts cover viagra

  • https://dasvibes.com/discography/gloria-megamix/
    Posted at 05:42h, 05 April

    Title

    […]Every the moment inside a whilst we select blogs that we read. Listed beneath are the latest sites that we decide on […]

  • https://www.theodysseyonline.com/11-top-tips-for-creating-a-functional-home-office
    Posted at 20:36h, 07 April

    Title

    […]The details talked about in the report are several of the most effective available […]

  • buy delta 8 THC
    Posted at 06:06h, 09 April

    Title

    […]Every as soon as in a although we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath are the most up-to-date sites that we choose […]

  • http://www.clubwww1.com/dating/member/blog_post_view.php?postId=90781
    Posted at 22:12h, 09 April

    Title

    […]The data mentioned inside the report are some of the top offered […]

  • where to buy delta 8
    Posted at 07:37h, 10 April

    Title

    […]check beneath, are some completely unrelated websites to ours, having said that, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  • Viagra cena
    Posted at 09:12h, 10 April

    Title

    […]we came across a cool internet site that you simply could possibly appreciate. Take a look should you want[…]

  • Cialis
    Posted at 16:44h, 10 April

    Title

    […]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not associated to ours, we feel they’re truly really worth a go as a result of, so possess a look[…]

  • tsescorts
    Posted at 18:13h, 10 April

    Title

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated data, nonetheless seriously really worth taking a search, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got a lot more problerms at the same time […]

  • para kazanma
    Posted at 21:32h, 10 April

    Title

    […]although web sites we backlink to below are considerably not associated to ours, we feel they may be really worth a go by, so possess a look[…]

  • The Revenant
    Posted at 10:36h, 13 April

    The Revenant

    The Revenant

  • 00-tv.com
    Posted at 11:46h, 14 April

    00-tv.com

    00-tv.com

  • 2021
    Posted at 12:45h, 14 April

    2021

    2021

  • Review and Bonus
    Posted at 14:27h, 14 April

    Title

    […]usually posts some really exciting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]

  • Wheelchair Van Repair Near Me
    Posted at 21:31h, 15 April

    Title

    […]Every the moment inside a whilst we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the newest sites that we choose […]

  • read more
    Posted at 23:27h, 17 April

    Title

    […]below you will obtain the link to some internet sites that we assume you must visit[…]

  • I am too scared to date again
    Posted at 10:07h, 18 April

    Title

    […]we like to honor a lot of other net internet sites on the web, even though they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Beneath are some webpages really worth checking out[…]

  • read my site
    Posted at 12:43h, 18 April

    Title

    […]we came across a cool web-site that you just may get pleasure from. Take a appear for those who want[…]

  • read more
    Posted at 21:46h, 18 April

    Title

    […]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not connected to ours, we really feel they are truly really worth a go by means of, so have a look[…]

  • Like This
    Posted at 22:13h, 18 April

    Title

    […]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[…]

  • click
    Posted at 01:15h, 19 April

    Title

    […]the time to study or stop by the content or websites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  • Like This
    Posted at 05:33h, 19 April

    Title

    […]Every as soon as inside a although we decide on blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the newest websites that we pick […]

  • Click Here
    Posted at 22:28h, 19 April

    Title

    […]one of our guests recently advised the following website[…]

  • D4
    Posted at 18:28h, 20 April

    D4

    D4

  • บาคาร่า168
    Posted at 22:03h, 21 April

    Title

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated data, nonetheless definitely worth taking a search, whoa did one particular understand about Mid East has got a lot more problerms at the same time […]

  • เอากัน
    Posted at 01:22h, 22 April

    Title

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a number of unrelated information, nevertheless truly worth taking a look, whoa did 1 master about Mid East has got much more problerms also […]

  • 777
    Posted at 00:34h, 23 April

    777

    777

  • slotxo
    Posted at 03:39h, 23 April

    Title

    […]just beneath, are numerous absolutely not associated sites to ours, nonetheless, they’re certainly really worth going over[…]

  • สมัคร
    Posted at 04:24h, 23 April

    Title

    […]we came across a cool site that you just might take pleasure in. Take a look if you want[…]

  • บาคาร่า
    Posted at 05:08h, 23 April

    Title

    […]here are some links to web pages that we link to for the reason that we think they are really worth visiting[…]

  • SEO
    Posted at 05:14h, 23 April

    Title

    […]here are some hyperlinks to web sites that we link to since we consider they’re worth visiting[…]

  • พนันบอล
    Posted at 08:27h, 23 April

    Title

    […]we like to honor a lot of other internet web pages on the net, even though they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Beneath are some webpages really worth checking out[…]

  • 7M
    Posted at 08:29h, 23 April

    Title

    […]one of our visitors not too long ago suggested the following website[…]

  • แทงหวยออนไลน์
    Posted at 08:49h, 23 April

    Title

    […]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[…]

  • หวยยี่กี
    Posted at 12:13h, 23 April

    Title

    […]we prefer to honor quite a few other world wide web websites on the internet, even though they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[…]

  • read more
    Posted at 15:42h, 23 April

    Title

    […]just beneath, are various totally not associated websites to ours, on the other hand, they’re surely worth going over[…]

  • read here
    Posted at 22:20h, 23 April

    Title

    […]we came across a cool internet site that you might take pleasure in. Take a look for those who want[…]

  • read more
    Posted at 00:40h, 24 April

    Title

    […]we prefer to honor lots of other net internet sites around the internet, even when they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages really worth checking out[…]

  • read more
    Posted at 08:46h, 24 April

    Title

    […]the time to read or go to the subject material or websites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  • click
    Posted at 09:57h, 24 April

    Title

    […]here are some links to web sites that we link to because we think they’re worth visiting[…]

  • pdt training
    Posted at 15:41h, 24 April

    Title

    […]we like to honor lots of other online web-sites on the net, even when they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Below are some webpages really worth checking out[…]

  • selling payment processing services
    Posted at 17:52h, 24 April

    Title

    […]check below, are some entirely unrelated web-sites to ours, on the other hand, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  • read more
    Posted at 17:48h, 25 April

    Title

    […]Here are a few of the websites we advise for our visitors[…]

  • click
    Posted at 20:07h, 25 April

    Title

    […]Here are a number of the web sites we advise for our visitors[…]

  • read more
    Posted at 00:15h, 26 April

    Title

    […]the time to study or pay a visit to the content material or internet sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]